Water Heater ReplacementOut in the Morning. In by Afternoon.
A dead water heater is an emergency. Most Central Indiana homes need a 40 or 50-gallon tank swap, which we handle in a single visit.
Standard electric or gas tank water heaters are a handyman-scope install when the existing lines are in place. We pull the old unit, haul it to the scrap yard, install the new one, connect supply/discharge/power or gas, test for leaks, and turn it back on. Most jobs: 3–5 hours.
Pricing
40-Gallon Tank Swap
Labor $450–$650 + heater ($450–$900). Total: $900–$1,550 installed.
50-Gallon Tank Swap
Labor $475–$700 + heater ($550–$1,050). Total: $1,025–$1,750 installed.
Upgrade from 40 to 50-Gal
Check existing space + venting. Usually add $100–$200 for line adjustments.
Tankless (gas or electric)
Labor $1,200–$1,800 + unit ($1,500–$3,500). Gas tankless needs venting — may add cost.
$150 minimum + materials. Haul-away of old unit is included.
Frequently Asked Questions
When should I replace my water heater?
Most tank water heaters last 10–15 years. Replace when: you see visible rust on the tank, water comes out discolored, the tank is leaking (not just a drip fitting), or it's 12+ years old and you need hot water to work reliably.
How long does a water heater install take?
Standard like-for-like tank swap: 3–5 hours. Tankless conversion: 6–8 hours (sometimes spread to 2 days if gas-line mods are needed).
Gas or electric water heater?
If you already have gas service to the unit, stay gas — cheaper to operate. If your home is electric-only, modern heat-pump electric water heaters are efficient and worth considering vs. standard resistance tanks.
Get Your Estimate
We respond within 24 hours on business days. Call, text, or email — whichever works.
$150 minimum + materials · Licensed & Insured · BBB A+ · 5.0 Google (64 reviews)
Estimate language: final invoice is based on actual labor hours + materials. Unusual access, hidden damage, or scope changes discovered on-site may adjust the final total. Nothing is billed without your approval.
Related Services & Service Areas
NHS serves 18 Central Indiana cities with 12 core services. Licensed, insured, and owner-operated since 2005.